trends, Karenia brevis might appear
more often in the South Atlantic Bight
of the US and Gymnodinium catenatum
bloom more often in northwestern Iberian waters. There was also a warning
by Barrie Dale germane to such speculations, that large scale climate models
cannot predict local changes.
Little more was heard of supposed
links between HABs and climate until two decades later in Hersonissos
(2010). The preface to the Hersonissos
proceedings claims that ...this conference included ... a solid body of 50 papers
and posters on climate change; if true,
few of them appeared in the proceedings, where the phrase climate change
appears in a single contribution about
Prymnesium parvum in some Texan
lakes, and the phrase global warming
only twice. There were speculations
that the appearance of Chattonella globosa and Dinophysis tripos in Norwegian coastal waters might be related to
global warming, similarly for Ostreopsis
ovata in the upper Adriatic.
Changing patterns of abundance on
decadal time scales were reported at
the Changwon conference (2012) for
species of Karenia, Cochlodinium, Chattonella, and Heterosigma in Korean and
Japanese waters, Pyrodinium in the
Philippines, Gymnodinium in Portugal,
Prorocentrum and Heterosigma in Narragansett Bay. As pointed out at the time
[14], some of these patterns may be
linked to regional effects of phenomena
like the PDO or ENSO; and some almost
certainly, as Patricia Glibert argues, to
eutrophication. As already mentioned,
disentangling the separate impacts of
climate and nutrient loading is a major
problem. AGW was not invoked, indeed
it is clear that we do not yet have an
adequate data base to do so [15]. Also
at Changwon, Barrie Dale warned that
available time series plankton data are
inadequate for establishing species responses to natural climate variations
and therefore offer no sound basis for
predicting effects of climate. The Wellington conference (2014) abstracts
contain the word climate only six times;
in the two contributions in which climate change was addressed directly
there, its impact on HABs was again enmeshed with eutrophication.
So what did participants at Florianópolis mean when they wrote of climate change? Was warming intended?
HARMFUL ALGAE NEWS NO. 59 / 2018
From the abstracts alone, it is hard to
know. A few clearly mean weather in
the sense used above. Are others jumping on a bandwagon? If so, they might
recall Gustaaf Hallegraeffs admonition:
Crying wolf does not serve our discipline
and we need to refrain from making unsubstantiated climate predictions! [16].
Science 2.0 was represented at Florianópolis [17, 18] by Jianguo Lius
coupled human and natural systems or
CHANS [19] and Tim Langs ecological
public health, EPH [20]. Both combine
ecosystem models with other complex
systems. CHANS are built by linking
models of economic, social, hydrological, atmospheric, and biological subsystems and interactions among them.
EPH combines more than just evidence,
and includes the open pursuit of social
values, highlighting the role of interest groups, and debate across society
not just within restricted scientific circles. Climate change is central to both
schemes. The novelty then is to weld
ecosystem dynamics with climate dynamics, add some flavours from outside
science, run some models, and see what
might happen.
Shneidermans Science 2.0 combines applied science, engineering, and
design and attempts to tackle problems
like disaster response systems or environmental sustainability [1]. These are
not purely scientific problems, and their
complexity makes it necessary to break
them into smaller pieces for analysis.
One of Shneidermans five strategies for
doing this is classical reductionist science [21]. It is therefore impossible to
accept the viewpoint of one participant
in the conference, that taxonomy, physiology, biogeography, and population
dynamics are no longer useful research
topics, that they will not adequately inform on purported climate change: HAB
linkages [22].
Even though complex models of the
climate or an ecosystem can exhibit
chaotic dynamics, with all the technical
challenges entailed, Science 2.0, EPH,
and CHANS propose to combine several
such systems in search of solutions to
economic and political problems. These
aspirations read like recipes for cybernetic gigantism [23]. We can agree that
solutions to complex problems demand
multidisciplinary approaches, and that
collaborative projects which combine
expertise from diverse disciplines are
potentially fruitful. But if science is to
be part of these activities, it must be
real science, not a debased imitation.
References
1. Schneiderman B 2016. The new ABCs
of research: achieving breakthrough
collaborations (Oxford University Press),
320 pp
2. ICHA 2016.Book of Abstracts. http://
icha2016.com/program/abstract-book.
pdf
3. Prakash A 1975. In: LoCicero VR(ed),
Proc 1st Intern Conf on Toxic Dinoflagellate Blooms (Mass Sci Technol Foundn,
Wakefield, Mass), pp 1-6
4. Smayda TJ 1989. In: Cosper EM et al
(eds), Novel Phytoplankton Blooms
(Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, New
York), pp 159-187
5. Hallegraeff GM 1993. Phycologia 32: 7999
6. Hallegraeff GM 2010. J Phycol 46: 220235
7. Lorenz E 1964. Tellus 6: 1-11. J Sea Res
2009. Vol 61(1), 124 pp
8. J Sea Res 2009. 61(1): 1-124
9. Wyatt T 2010. In: Briand F (ed), Phytoplankton responses to Mediterranean environmental changes. CIESM Workshop
Monographs N 40 (CIESM Publisher,
Monaco), 120 pp
10. Yin K 2016. Abstract OS1805, p 59 in [2]
11. White A 1987. Rap Proces 187: 38-46
12. Yasuda I 2006. Geophys Res Lett 33
L08606, 4 pp
13. Yndestad H et al 2008. Deep Sea Research I 55: 1201-1217
14. Wyatt T 2013. HAN 47: 1-3
15. Dale B et al 2006. In: Granéli E & Turner
JT (eds), Ecology of Harmful Algae
(Springer-Verlag), pp 367-378
16. Hallegraeff GM 2011. HAN 43: 11-12
17. Fleming L 2016. Abstract KN02, p 6 in [2]
18. Lintott L 2016. Abstract POS0128, p 115
in [2]
19. Liu J et al 2007. Ambio 36: 639649
20. Lang T & G Rayner 2012. BMJ 2012 Aug
21;345:e5466. doi: 10.1136/bmj.e5466
21. Wyatt T 2017. Ethics Sci Envir Polit 17:
51-62, DOI: https://doi.org/10.3354/
esep00177
22. Wells M 2016. Abstract PS06, p 9 in [2]
23. Marshall A 1998. Stud Hist Philos Sci Pt
C. Stud Hist Phil Biol & Biomed Sci 29:
137-164
Author
Tim Wyatt, Borreiros Gondomar, Pontevedra,
Spain
Email: timwyatt1937@gmail.com
19
Harmful Algae News An IOC Newsletter on Toxic Algae and Algal Blooms No. 59 - February 2018 www.ioc-unesco.org/hab Content 25 years of HAN and IPHAB...... 1 25 YEARS Harmful Algae News was first published in early 1992 in response to requests from the participants at a number of IOC meetings and
pacted by harmful algal events. Since Harmful Algae News turned 20 years old in 2012, it has been a web based e-newsletter which meant longer issues were possible and back issues easily accessible. We are currently working on a searchable index for all Harmful Algae News issues. The start of Harmful
Intergovernmental Panel on Harmful Algal Blooms also turned 25! During 1992, the same Year as the IOC published the first issue of Harmful Algal News, it also established an Intergovernmental Panel on Harmful Algal Blooms (IPHAB) which has met every second year since it was formed. The Panel is com
A retrospective look at the early days of HAB cyst research, and a look to the future On this occasion of the 25th anniversary of the publication of Harmful Algae News, several of us were asked to look backwards in time to some of the earlier days of HAB science. One area of study that has been a ma
dormant stages and that these stages might be associated with certain bottom sediments. This then brings up the question, if benthic resting stages of certain dinoflagellates actually seed coastal red tides, are there localized areas of accumulation, or what we could call seedbeds?..........The poss
day, we still do not know if there are other factors at work perhaps a density-dependent or quorum-sensing type of response, or even a response to the presence of grazers or parasites. Exploration of this response has long been limited by the constraints associated with laboratory cultures, but now
approach did not stand up to data at my study locations. I raise this issue in this narrative because I want to correct what I feel are unjustified recommendations that may prevent those working on cysts from obtaining the type of biological data that can advance our understanding of certain types o
number of cysts in subsurface layers unable to germinate or emerge, presumably due to lack of oxygen or to the tortuous pathway posed by sediment grains and detritus. Many might think that major storms and waves can erode significant layers of sediment and transport cysts long distances, but here ag
How do algal blooms kill finfish and how can we mitigate their impacts? Algal blooms, water discolorations and their association with fish kills have been recorded since historic times, such as the description in the Bible (1000 years BC) all the waters that were in the river were turned to blood. A
Table. 1. Economic losses from algal blooms for finfish aquaculture in different parts of the world HAB species Chattonella Heterosigma Cochlodinium polykrikoides Heterosigma Chaetoceros Heterosigma Karenia digitata Karenia mikimotoi Country Financial Losses Japan Korea, China Canada British Col
emergency harvest operations. To prevent the buildup of histamines, fish should be kept alive as long as possible during harvesting. This can be achieved by diluting algal concentrations via airlift upwelling, or by targeted in-pen emergency application of clays [23] that mop up ichthyotoxins at cla
As part of the 25th anniversary issue of Harmful Algal News I am providing an overview of the IOC-UNESCO Taxonomic Reference List of Harmful Algae (www. marinespecies.org/hab/) and will highlight some of the problems which have faced or are facing the Intergovernmental Panel on Harmful Algal Blooms
Dinophyceae the authors intended the new genus to be described according to the botanical nomenclature. The lack of a Latin diagnosis therefore made it invalid. The confusion has actually still not been resolved, and the problem needs to be discussed and decided upon by the International Nomenclatur
geographically widespread species being able to form fertile offspring, while other populations of the same species are not. Molecular techniques have contributed very significantly to solving many taxonomic problems, but they have not resulted in the emergence of a finite species concept. We have t
Algal toxin discovery, management and regulation over the last 25 years Algal toxins in the dark ages (pre-1992) From a historic perspective, knowledge about algal toxins can be divided into truly prehistoric occurrences such as known from paleontological studies [1-2] and more recent historic recor
lar rapid increase in known analogues has been observed for the azaspiracid (AZA) group, with the first analogue described in 1998 [64] and a review in 2014 reporting 30 analogues [65]. Only three years later, over 50 analogues are known for this group, including novel phosphate derivatives [66-71].
Butterflies in Brazil Abstracts are not always reliable guides to authors intentions. They are not expected to reveal a great deal about the evidence to be deployed in support of the science, evidence that may not even exist before deadlines for writing abstracts! Nevertheless, as examples of a mino
on a decadal time scale, and identified palaeoclimatic oscillations are not necessarily a useful guide to its interpretation. An obvious obstacle to detecting climate signals in HAB data is posed by anthropogenic eutrophication. Another obstacle is the fact that phytoplankton respond directly to the
trends, Karenia brevis might appear more often in the South Atlantic Bight of the US and Gymnodinium catenatum bloom more often in northwestern Iberian waters. There was also a warning by Barrie Dale germane to such speculations, that large scale climate models cannot predict local changes. Little m
Red tides in Kamchatka coastal waters (Bering Sea, Russia) are a barrier for the salmon fishery and Pacific salmon Fig. 1. Map of Olyutorskiy Bay (Kamchatka, Bering Sea) where a red tide, reported by fishermen, occurred in July 2017. The stars denote fishery sites: red, affected by the bloom; green
Fig. 2. Red tide in Olyutorskiy Bay on 15th July 2017 grounds of the Olyutorskiy Bay river basin performed during the second half of August showed an atypical distribution in the rivers. Maximal escapes were recorded in river basins located in the western and eastern parts of the Olyutorskiy Bay ar
First report of Gambierdiscus in the Western Mediterranean Sea (Balearic Islands) Gambierdiscus (Dinophyceae) species are benthic dinoflagellates living in marine littoral zones of circumtropical areas and have recently been described in temperate waters [1]. Some species are producers of potent neu
the SEASENSING (BIO2014-56024C2-2-R) project and the CERCA Programme/Generalitat de Catalunya. A. Tudó and A. Toldrà acknowledge IRTAURV-Banco Santander for their respective PhD grants (2016 PMF-PIPF-74 and 2015PMF-PIPF-67). The authors are grateful to Vanessa Castan and José Luis Costa for sampling
Comparison by light microscopy and qPCR of potentially ichthyotoxic microalgae in Danish on-shore lagoons producing European flounder (Platichthys flesus): Pros and cons of microscopical and molecular methods Fig. 1. Lagoon used for production of European flounder at Fishlab, Denmark. Evaluation o
Fig. 2. Comparison of phytoplankton species identification and cell densities (cells L-1) by qPCR (A and C) and light microscopy (target species and groups which potentially could comprise ichthyotoxic organisms) (B and D) in lagoon 1 (A and B) and lagoon 6 (C and D), respectively. The right Y-axis
present in a sample then qPCR would miss those probably due to lack of a developed assay. However, LM does require high levels of taxonomic skills and the precision in identification is only as accurate as the taxonomist allows. Different taxonomists trained in different ways using different identif
As qPCR measures genetic material rather than viable cells an over estimation of cell numbers can occur due to the inclusion of dead or dying cells. Problems may also occur when targeting multiple copy genes where the organism carries different numbers of the target depending on nutritional status,
The Cawthron Institute Culture Collection of Micro-algae (CICCM) The CICCM is designated as a nationally significant database by the New Zealand government and so receives partial funding for its continued existence. Isolates from 13 classes of micro-algae are maintained either as live cultures or c
The XVIII International Conference on Harmful Algae is approaching! It is time for nominations for achievement awards (Yasumoto Life Time and Patrick Gentien Young Scientist), registration to the conference as a student if you wish to participate in the Maureen Keller Award competition and fundraisi
Forthcoming Events First announcement of the 11th International Conference on Toxic Cyanobacteria (ICTC) We are pleased to disseminate the first announcement of the 11th International Conference on Toxic Cyanobacteria (ICTC) that will be held in Krakow, Poland from May 5 10, 2019. The ICTC is a per
International Coordination of Research on Harmful Algal Blooms From GEOHAB to GlobalHAB International cooperation is fundamental to advance understanding of HAB dynamics and to improve our ability to predict them. Fostering this international cooperation was the mission of GEOHAB (Global Ecology and
18th International Conference on Harmful Algae www.icha2018.com IMPORTANT DEADLINES Abstract submission deadline: 15 April 2018 Early bird registration: 15 July 2018 Get the 17 ICHA Proceedings at www.issha.org Eds-in-chief Beatriz Reguera, IEO, Vigo, Spain Eilen Bresnan, MARLAB, Scotland, UK Regi